Final Thoughts
when beginning a 1 to 1 program. I was interested to hear how an International School in Hong Kong
facilitates it's 1:1 Program. It seemed a lot 'tighter' than the way our
trial was structured and I wonder if this is a good thing or not? The
speed at which my children picked things up, escalated with the
opportunity to take their computers home. However, as it was optional to
take the computers home, it made it difficult to assign homework tasks
involving the computers when some children would not have them. Just
watching their confidence in themselves as IT users was probably the
biggest 'up-side' for me. Since reverting to the older computers, shared with three other classes,
we have daily 'longed' for our laptops back. They are faster, more
reliable, less likely to fail us and best of all, they were ours which
meant in addition to our school server, we were able to just save to the
hard drive if the server was slow or busy. Having our own internet server
was also amazing and we loved how fast the internet was. As a creative outlet, I feel like I have lost a lot with not having the
computers. I was so impressed with many of the tools the students were
using to organize their thinking or share their work, including short
clips via the Photobooth into explanations of their work etc. The quality
of the computers, the time constraints associated with sharing and the
lack of reliability mean some of these ways of sharing our knowing are no
longer available to us. I would be interested in seeing how the iPad compares. I think as
feedback goes in to Apple about use in schools and more apps are made that
will make it more of a tool and less of a toy, it would be a very
economically and educationally viable option to consider pads over books. The addition of a webcam would be a start, along with a way of syncing the
iPads simultaneously as this could be a very time consuming feature of the
iPads. Overall, I am very grateful to have been given the opportunity to trial
this 1:1 program. Yes, I am a strong advocate for IT integration in
education, however I think we still need to make sure that we are
introducing these programs with the appropriate support and training for
teachers and students (and parents!) who are less familiar and comfortable
with a Mac platform. As with any new scheme, it is not just the initial
financial obligation, but the ongoing commitment to upgrade, upskill and
support through dedicated IT personnel or IT training for all staff. We
would also need to consider parental 'buy in' as lack of this will
negatively impact the success of the scheme.


